Landscape Design

A healthy, green lawn begins with the right care at the right time. With regular attention, it grows thick, vibrant, and looks its best. One of the best ways to maintain it is through aeration and overseeding, two proven techniques that enhance lawn health from the roots up.

These two steps are simple yet effective, breaking up hard soil, improving airflow, and filling bare spots with healthy new grass. Aeration allows water and nutrients to reach the roots. Overseeding thickens grass and helps push out weeds.

In this guide, you’ll learn the benefits of these steps and how to do them for the best results. Follow these steps, and you’ll be on your way to a greener, stronger lawn.

What Is Aeration?

Aeration is the process of removing small plugs of soil from your lawn. These plugs are usually 1 to 2 inches long and a few inches apart. The holes left behind loosen compacted soil and help your grass absorb what it needs to thrive.

The process has the following steps;

  1. A machine with hollow tines pulls plugs out of the soil.
  2. The plugs are left on the surface to break down naturally.
  3. The lawn is typically aerated in two directions (crisscross pattern).

The best time to do this is when the grass is actively growing. It also has the following benefits:

  • It opens up tightly packed soil that blocks water, nutrients, and oxygen from reaching the roots. 
  • The holes let air, water, and fertilizer reach deep into the root zone. 
  • The soil plugs contain microbes that break down thatch and improve soil health.
  • More access to nutrients means deeper, healthier roots and greener grass.

When Does Your Lawn Need Aeration?

You should aerate if your lawn has heavy foot traffic from kids, pets, or lawn equipment. To decide if aeration is a good idea, look for these indicators:

  • Water puddles on the surface instead of soaking in.
  • The lawn feels hard when you walk on it.

You should do it annually to maintain the overall health of your lawn. Also, it is important to aerate your lawn before overseeding to help the seed reach the soil. 

What Is Overseeding?

Overseeding is the process of spreading new grass seed over your existing lawn to enhance its thickness, resilience, and appearance. Rather than using too much seed, it’s about introducing the right seed varieties to improve your lawn’s overall health and density.

By overseeding, you can:

  • Encourage new, healthy grass growth that complements your existing turf beautifully.

  • Fill in bare or thinning patches to create a more even lawn surface.

  • Introduce grass types that are better equipped to resist disease and drought.

  • Build a thicker, fuller lawn that naturally helps block out weeds.

  • Restore the vibrant look of your lawn without the need to start from scratch.

  • Improve your lawn’s color, making it look lush, green, and revitalized.

This process can restore your lawn, making it look lush, green, and healthy.

When Should You Overseed?

The best time to overseed is right after aeration, when the soil is loose and ready. Early fall or spring works best for cool-season grasses, and late spring to early summer is ideal for warm-season grasses.

Overseeding should be done anytime your lawn looks thin, uneven, or damaged. Pairing it with core aeration will give you the best chance at long-term results. However, before you begin, you need to prepare your lawn.

How to Prepare Your Lawn Before Aeration

Preparing your lawn before aeration ensures better results and helps protect underground fixtures. 

Here’s how to prep it the right way:

1. Mow the Lawn Shorter

Before aerating, lower your mower blade slightly to give your grass seed the best chance to succeed:

  • Cut your grass somewhat lower than normal
  • Makes it easier for the aerator to reach the soil
  • Helps grass seed contact the ground if you’re overseeding

2. Clear All Debris

Make sure the lawn is free of anything that could block or damage the aerator during use:

  • Remove sticks, rocks, leaves, and lawn furniture
  • Prevents blockages and keeps aerator tines from getting stuck
  • Ensures consistent plug removal across the lawn

3. Water One to Two Days Before

Proper soil moisture makes aeration more effective and easier on your equipment:

  • Lightly water your lawn a day or two ahead
  • Softens the soil for deeper, cleaner plugs
  • Avoid watering right before aerating (muddy soil won’t help)

4. Mark Underground Fixtures

Take safety steps to avoid damaging essential lines or systems hidden in your lawn:

  • Flag sprinkler heads, invisible fences, and shallow utility lines
  • Avoids accidental damage from aerator spikes

Once your lawn is fully prepped, you're ready to start aerating. The process begins with picking the right tool for the job.

Types of Aerators and How to Choose One

Choosing the right aerator can significantly impact the effectiveness of your aeration efforts. Here’s what you need to know about the main types and when to use them:

1. Core (Hollow Tine) Aerators: Best for Most Lawns

These aerators remove small plugs of soil and leave open holes behind, making them the top choice for compacted lawns:

  • Loosen dense soil and reduce compaction
  • Improve airflow, water absorption, and nutrient delivery
  • Help roots grow deeper and stronger
  • Ideal for clay-heavy or high-traffic lawns

2. Solid Tine Aerators: Light Aeration Only

Instead of removing soil, these tools poke holes into the ground, which can sometimes compress the surrounding soil:

  • Suitable for sandy or already loose soils.
  • Useful for routine maintenance, not major compaction.
  • Less effective in preparing for overseeding.

Aerating and overseeding your lawn is a straightforward process, but doing it correctly makes all the difference. Follow these five steps to help your grass grow thicker, stronger, and healthier.

Renting one is cost-effective if you don’t own an aerator. To save even more:

  • Rent from local garden centers or equipment stores.
  • Expect to pay around $100 for a day.
  • Ask neighbors to split the cost and take turns using it.

Always use a core aerator for compacted or neglected lawns that delivers better long-term results.

Step-by-Step Guide to Aerating and Overseeding

Step 1: Aerate the Lawn

Start using a core aerator to pull small plugs of soil from your lawn. Follow these pointers for the best results:

  • Aerate in a crisscross pattern to ensure complete coverage.
  • Focus on areas with visible compaction or thinning.
  • Leave the plugs on the surface; they’ll break down and return nutrients to the soil. over time

Aeration opens the soil, allowing water, air, and seed to move freely through the root zone.

Step 2: Spread Grass Seed

Select a high-quality seed blend that matches your grass type and local climate conditions.

  • Use a broadcast or drop spreader for even coverage
  • Follow the seeding rate on the seed label, but don’t overdo it
  • For patchy areas, apply slightly more to ensure complete coverage

This step fills bare spots and strengthens thin regions, creating a denser lawn.

Step 3: Rake Lightly

Once the seed is down, rake the lawn gently to help it settle.

  • Use a soft rake to mix the seed slightly into the soil
  • Focus on getting seed into the aeration holes for better germination
  • Avoid heavy raking, which can disrupt existing grass

Seed-to-soil contact is key to good germination.

Step 4: Water the Lawn

Watering is critical in the early stages of seed growth.

  • Keep the soil consistently moist for the first 2–3 weeks
  • Water lightly once or twice a day until seeds sprout
  • Once the grass is 2–3 inches tall, reduce to deeper, less frequent watering

This encourages stronger root development over time.

Step 5: Fertilize After Aeration

Apply a gentle starter fertilizer to feed the new seedlings.

A balanced starter fertilizer provides your grass with the essential nutrients it needs to establish quickly and grow thick.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Here are the most common mistakes homeowners make during aeration and overseeding, and how to avoid them:

1. Aerating in Poor Soil Conditions

Avoid aerating when the soil is too dry or too wet. Here’s why:

  • Dry soil is difficult to penetrate.
  • Wet soil turns muddy, leading to messy plugs and soil compaction.

Tip: Water lightly 1–2 days before aerating for ideal moisture.

2. Overseeding Without Proper Prep

Skipping prep means the seed may never reach the soil.

  • Failing to mow or clear debris blocks seed from settling.
  • Lack of soil contact leads to poor germination.
  • Always prepare your lawn before overseeding to give new grass the best chance to grow.

3. Wrong Seed Selection or Over-Application

Using the wrong grass seed, or too much of it, will only waste time and money. Take the following steps to prevent that:

  • Match the seed to your region and lawn conditions.
  • Overseeding doesn’t mean dumping extra seed.
  • Follow the label for correct seeding rates and grass type.

4. Inconsistent Watering

Watering too little or infrequently can kill new grass before it takes hold. Seeds need daily moisture to germinate; dry soil will stall growth or kill seedlings. 

Ensure that you Water lightly every day until seedlings are established.

5. Incorrect Use of Herbicides

Herbicides used too soon can harm new seedlings. It’s essential to avoid preemergent weed control before or right after seeding. 

Wait several weeks after overseeding before applying any weed products. Check the label and time your herbicide applications carefully to ensure accuracy.

Final Tips for Long-Term Lawn Health

Aeration and overseeding give your lawn a strong foundation, but lasting results come from consistent care. A routine of mowing, fertilizing, and seasonal maintenance will keep your grass dense and healthy.

Avoid walking on newly seeded areas until the grass is fully established and has grown to a height of at least 2 inches. If you notice thinning spots over time, touch up with seed quickly to maintain even growth. Adding compost or mulch can enhance soil quality and promote deeper, stronger root growth.

Most importantly, stay consistent. A great lawn doesn’t happen once. It happens year after year through steady effort and proper support.

At Percy’s Lawn Care, we understand that a healthy lawn doesn’t happen overnight. It takes experience, attention to detail, and steady care. Since 1999, families and businesses across Buffalo, Amherst, and Cheektowaga have trusted us to keep their outdoor spaces clean, safe, and thriving year-round. 

We offer a one-stop solution for lawn care, offering services that include weekly mowing, seasonal cleanups, custom landscaping, and dependable snow removal during the winter. 

With two generations of hands-on experience, we focus on delivering high-quality work and treating every lawn we work on as if it were our own.

If your lawn needs a boost or you want to prepare your property for the next season, our team is here to help with honest and reliable service. 

Contact Percy’s Lawn Care and Son today for a complimentary consultation and discover how we can bring lasting beauty and functionality to your outdoor space.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. How do I know if my lawn needs aeration?
Your lawn likely needs aeration if the soil feels hard or water pools on the surface.

2. Can I aerate and overseed on the same day?
Yes. Aerating before seeding helps the new grass seed establish itself in the soil.

3. What type of grass seed should I use?
Use a seed that matches your current lawn and is suited to your local climate. Percy’s Lawn Care can recommend the best option for your yard.

4. How soon should I water after overseeding?
Water right after spreading the seed. For the first 2 to 3 weeks, water daily to keep the soil lightly moist.

5. When can I mow after overseeding?
Wait until new grass is at least 3 inches tall. Use sharp blades and avoid cutting more than one-third of the grass height.

6. Can I use weed control products during this process?
No. Most herbicides can damage new seedlings. Wait several weeks after seeding before applying any weed control.

7. How often should I aerate and overseed my lawn?
Once a year is ideal for most lawns; high-traffic or compacted lawns may benefit from being mowed twice a year.

8. What’s the best time of year to aerate and overseed?
Cool-season grasses do best in early fall or spring, while warm-season grasses benefit most from late spring through early summer.

9. Will Percy’s Lawn Care handle aeration and overseeding for me?
Yes. We offer full-service aeration and overseeding across Buffalo, Amherst, and Cheektowaga.

10. How much does professional aeration and overseeding cost?
Costs vary depending on lawn size and the services required. Contact Percy’s Lawn Care for a free consultation and quote.